Genre Fiction Commentary – Originality in Fantasy

31 May


Wanna hear a joke? Well since you’re here I guess you’re at least willing to humor me.

So a Fantasy author sits down to plan his first big novel. He smiles, pen in hand, and leans back in his chair.

“Man,” he says with an excited grin, “The best thing about fantasy is that I can make it anything I want. Could be based on any culture in any place from any time. Could be a mix of places and times, or something newly invented by me. Yup, there is literally nothing out of bounds here.”

He looks at his page for about ten seconds. As the pen hits the paper he says “Let’s go with Medieval England!

Now, back to the plot!

Fantasy is a fun genre. It allows us to explore countless worlds and go places only imagination can take us. It challenges us to take the first step into the unknown in the same way (insert protagonist here) does. It can be epic in scale, it can be personal. In this world of infinite possibilities the only thing it can’t be is predictable.

And yet it is.

Story time: When pitching my Senior Project to a friend I told her it was a Fantasy Drama. I was elated when she gasped, wide eyed, at the possibilities my story could bring. The she asked me, “Oh! Is the protagonist some hunky knight trying to save a princess from a dragon in a castle?” Whether she was condescending or not I’ll never know, but I do know that her question left a bad taste in my mouth.

More so than the sheer “wrongness” of her summary, what vexed me the most about our interaction was how quick she was to assume my story could be fit into such a cut-and-paste explanation. And yet, the more I thought about it, the more I realized her simple query was quite valid.

Fantasy, for all its possibilities, is in a ghetto as of late. When Fantasy enthusiasts are portrayed, they often are depicted as some variation of this:

And while i’m all for people loving what they love, I can’t stand the notion that the things I love are so simply caricatured and defined. Like a bad joke, Fantasy gets stereotyped and often made as a joke for those who enjoy it. I mean, why else would they have to make “Adult Covers” of Harry Potter?
See Subject A ^

And yet, I suppose it’s time to ask ourselves: are we, Fantasy fans, partially responsible for this stereotyping? Do we write and read only books in that familiar Medieval England setting, not deigning to step out into the world of more original works of fiction? I’ll admit I too stick to the conventions of fantasy more than I should, and for that I feel as though I am partially responsible for this mess.

So what is to be done? Well, that begins with originality.

Originality, as it’s appropriately named, can breathe new life into even the most dying of tropes. After Airplane came out, no one took Disaster Movies, but when Independence Day came out the genre suddenly became enjoyable once more. Soon afterward we had a flood of disaster movies like Dante’s Peak and Titanic, both of which were enjoyable additions to the genre.

Innovation can revive interest and understanding but that only comes when one has the guts to try something on their own. George R.R. Martin in particular uses the Medieval England setting for his Song of Ice and Fire series. However, rather than focus on the Dragons and Chivalry tropes that have been done to death he focuses on the politics and problems such a society brings. It’s his willingness to try something entirely of his own invention that made Game of Thrones such a hit, and is why Fantasy is seen in a much more appropriate light now than it was ten years ago.

As Winston Churchill once said “Without tradition, art is a flock of sheep without a shepherd. Without innovation, it is a corpse.” The same can be said of any genre, and while conventions exist for a reason, it is a major disservice to both the reader and the writer to stick to them in fear of the unknown.

Be like the protagonist of your story and dare to step into the unmarked territory, and be unafraid for the lessons that brought you to the Journey’s threshold will serve you well.

Sorry for the long post. I’ll be sure to keep my thoughts more concise next time.
Do you all have a favorite genre of your own? Do you ever feel like stories in said genre are stagnate? How would you overcome them? Any experiences in doing so?

If not, then farewell, until next time. Keep on trekking.


Posted by on May 31, 2013 in Fantasy, Uncategorized


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

10 responses to “Genre Fiction Commentary – Originality in Fantasy

  1. Keri Arrage

    May 31, 2013 at 3:43 pm

    Hi, Zach. Very funny!

    • writemindedrazo

      June 3, 2013 at 3:14 pm

      Glad you like it. I update every Tuesday, Friday, and Sunday.

  2. emilyramos

    May 31, 2013 at 3:55 pm

    Innovation is good, but I don’t think it will solve everything. After all, the cycle is that a new, innovative book comes out and, if it becomes popular, it gets copied. The copying makes the innovation boring again. Think about it. It happened with vampire novels (though honestly that genre needs to get back to some good old Anne Rice roots), it has happened with the dystopian (I think the “Hunger Games” books were the cutting edge of this – but I’ve read several others that pale in comparison – and were published later) and it happens in fantasy.
    Humans are talented at mimicry. In a Writer’s Digest article that I read there was a comment about reading a book with a style similar to what you want for twenty minutes before writing. Now I don’t think writer’s should intentionally be trying to mimic others’ styles, but the point is that when all we have are the same old plots, settings, and heroes, that is all that we are going to write. After all, most heroes in fantasy somehow traumatized by their childhood, lacking parental figures, YOUNG, and quite often male. These are the foundations of fantasy, and most writers follow them. It makes it hard to break out.
    That being said, it’s not impossible and I encourage you to work towards innovation!
    Good luck!

    • writemindedrazo

      May 31, 2013 at 4:12 pm

      Innovation by itself means we have to strive to try out new things. As I mentioned earlier you can use the same tropes always found in genre fiction and still write something exciting.

      But yes, a stage needs actors, plot, and motifs to drive it forward, that much will never change. I’m saying we shouldn’t be content with mimicry, but then again that’s what second drafts are for.

      • emilyramos

        May 31, 2013 at 4:17 pm

        Yes, I agree, my comment was agreement and elaboration 🙂

  3. Richard Razo

    June 2, 2013 at 5:34 pm

    What I find interesting about this topic…I enjoy essays, poems, short stories and novels that use the cliche story lines to discuss contemporary issues that plague us or interest us.

  4. munchkinwrites

    June 3, 2013 at 1:59 pm

    A very insightful post! I pick up fantasy books from the shelf with a dash of caution, because so many plots and themes have been overused. I crave something original that will take my breath away, or something that may use common ideas but still pulls me into that familiar emotional and adventurous journey. I’m even more careful writing my own fantasy story right now, worrying over how to develop it properly. But at the end of the day, fantasy done well is one of the most rewarding genre and I’ve learnt to love it as unconditionally as I can.

    Thanks for sharing!

  5. Johne970

    June 22, 2014 at 11:17 am

    I don’t usually comment but I gotta admit thanks for the post on this great one ffcgcddefgdg


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Tupelo Press

Live from the Loft


the Eerdmans blog

Fred Colton

Posts To Delete Later

Living In Italy.Moving To Italy. Loving In Italy. Laughing In Italy.

"American Expat In Italy. A Hysterical Struggle With Language, Love, And Culture"-Probably Someone


Just another site


Want to see what an Instagram with no pictures looks like? @allmostrelevant

TheCoevas official blog

Strumentisti di Parole/Musicians of words

Adult & Teen Fiction

Read on and I will show you another world within this one....

Interesting Literature

A Library of Literary Interestingness

Street Photographer Blog

“I am not an artist. I am an image maker.” – Thomas Hoepker


Where heroes are born.


easy reading is damn hard writing

Ray Ferrer - Emotion on Canvas

** OFFICIAL Site of Artist Ray Ferrer **

Street of Dreams

A literary blog of poet, playwright and essayist Rachael Stanford

Sophie Bowns

“Without leaps of imagination or dreaming, we lose the excitement of possibilities. Dreaming, after all is a form of planning.” ― Gloria Steinem

A Journalist's Fantasy

Learning the ropes of the digital age, while staying true to my love of words

C.N. Faust

Writer of Fantasy and Horror

The Favorite Aunt

Feminism in the Family

%d bloggers like this: